Out of Disaster Comes New Life

I finished a book recently which told the story of the Big Burn forest fire that occurred in 1910. Three million acres were burned in Northern Idaho, W. Montana, Eastern Washington, and parts of Southeast British Columbia. Aside from the devastation to forest land, Timothy Egan tells the story of the origins of the US Forest Service. I am always interested in seeing the backstory on things and this book tells it.   The interesting tale related was how much the sitting President, Teddy Roosevelt, had valued conservation along with his associate Gifford Pinchot. Mr. Pinchot spent his whole life dedicated to the establishment and preservation of the National Parks and National Forests under the Roosevelt and Taft administrations. Timothy Egan spins an interesting side tale on the personality of Pinchot that is  worth reading.

Egan goes on to point out that the large forest fire and the resulting inquiries into the efforts of the rangers under the US Forest Service, were combative. Similar to today’s politics, there was national interest in conservation and the support of the USFS. The  opposition saw the USFS as a waste of time and government money.  In the opposition camp, were congressmen and senators who supported large scale logging and pillaging of the American West. Roosevelt fought hard against these lobbies and along with Pinchot, who later became Governor of Pennsylvania, kept the fight for conservation alive. In the end, the Forest Service was funded handsomely by congress and the lumber lobby eventually gave its support if only to keep the potential harvest in tact.

The compelling result of the fire, establishment of the US Forest Service and final support, let to the continued development of the National Parks Service and the continued development  of the National Forests and Monuments. The difference between a National Forest and a National Park is that the National Forests encourage use by the public to include skiing, mountain biking, fishing, and other outdoor pursuits. The National Parks are somewhat limited to public use other than observation with strict regulation of activities within the Parks. A little more stringent but a different ethos in preserving the pristine environment. However, with the foresight of people like Teddy Roosevelt, and Gifford Pinchot, we have these national treasures which are available to all of us.

I have had the good fortune of visiting Yosemite National Park with my wife and son a number of years ago and along with yearly trips to Mammoth Mountain Ski Area within the Inyo National Forest and visits to the Tahoe ski areas within the Tahoe National Forest,I am always impressed with the beauty and immense wilderness that is preserved. Janet and I also make use of the Allegheny National Forest near our home here in Pennsylvania along with use of many State parks along the way.

Recently I had the great experience of riding mountain bikes in the Deschutes National Forest in Bend, Oregon and was amazed at the quality of the trails and the maintenance of miles and miles of trail systems through this national forest. A lot of this maintenance in the national forests could not happen without the efforts of volunteers who preserve and develop trail systems for multi- use.

It all came together for me when I read this book ” The Big Burn” and realized that there was a lot of time, effort and anguish, in the establishment of national land and the need for preservation and conservation facilitated by the USFS. Not every available piece of land should be deemed for development. There has to be recreational opportunities for our children and grandchildren and I am grateful that men like Pinchot and Roosevelt, back at the turn of the century, had that same vision. If you get the chance to ever visit a State Park, a National Park, or National Forest, do it. You will see how a disastrous fire back in 1910 led to the conservation efforts which have served all Americans for well over a century. Hooray for Teddy Roosevelt- Bully!!!!!

If you like my weekly musings, please enter your email to the left here and be a follower. Or scroll down all the way on your smart phone and enter there. I appreciate it.

10 thoughts on “Out of Disaster Comes New Life

  1. jim fedako says:

    Bully for Teddy?

    Does it matter the Founders and those who voted for the Constitution never envisioned the federal government having such power? Does it matter that the federal government “owns” 28 percent of the US land?

    You could say, “Without Teddy, there would be no parks.” However, that assumes the states, which comprise the very same folks who are the US, could not and would not have set aside lands. Such an argument is a fallacy of composition.

    Bully for Teddy? Sure. But it was the Constitution and the citizens that were bullied by Teddy.

    (Note: He wasn’t the first, nor the last, president to trample the Constitution. But you must put his actions in perspective, even if you appreciate the results.)

    • patmccloskey says:

      Jim- respectfully the fallacy of composition is the notion that the states would have done anything back at the turn of the century with regards to conservation. Especially the western states where lawless boom towns were the rule of the day. I think had Teddy and Gifford not run up against the lumber lobbies and the railroads, our national parks and national forests would have looked tragically different. I am a states rights guy for sure. Jeffersonian in approach and not big on big government. However in this time, in this place in the country’s development, I think there was no choice if one was passionate about the environment. Just my opinion.

      • jfedako says:

        Understood, Pat.

        However, you do not show your Jeffersonian bona fides by accepting Jeffersonian principles only when convenient, Similar to me saying (arguendo) that I am a supporter of free speech … as long it doesn’t offend me (of course, Jefferson was always Jeffersonian).

        You have your parks … but what of those who property rights continue to be trampled to provide your recreational areas and vistas?

        It’s certainly fair to say you enjoy the parks, I do as well. However, it’s another thing altogether to champion the maniacal, Progressive mentality of someone like Teddy, even when you appreciate the outcome.

        Just sayin’.

        (Note: You might want to balance out your history readings with other viewpoints.)

      • patmccloskey says:

        Noted and thanks for commenting Jim. Hope all is well?

      • jfedako says:

        Living the country life on a quasi farm north of Sunbury, Ohio, with goats, cats, and sometimes cows. Plus trying to keep everyone ideologically pure 🙂

      • patmccloskey says:

        Sounds like a great lifestyle for sure.

  2. skimeister says:

    Great post Pat! Interestingly we were in the Bend OR area this summer. We traveled through portions of the Deschutes National Forest, particularly the Three Sisters Wilderness, the Mt Washington Wilderness and Camp Sherman, Springs of the Metolius River. As you say, it is beautiful country.

  3. […] February 8, 2020 by Adrienne Abe Leave a Comment January 27, 2020 […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s